‘Do you eat?’ What happened when Guardian readers tried to contact Martians

‘Do you eat?’ What happened when Guardian readers tried to contact Martians

If you could send a message to the Martians, what would you say to them?

That was the question the Guardian asked readers in 1929 when the newspaper launched a new competitions page. The challenge sat alongside the first crossword puzzle, and posed a different sort of challenge from the puzzles and games we publish today.

What the puzzle had in common with today’s offerings was that it was – as the editors of the day put it – “designed rather to afford the reader relaxation and amusement in an easy chair, a train or a tram, than to tax all the resources alike of his intelligence and of his library”.

The reader of 1929 would have been well advised to dig into those resources, though, as the prize offered for the best answer was two guineas, the equivalent of about £120 today.

The question captured readers’ imaginations, and the Guardian received hundreds of responses. Unemployment was among the main concerns raised by Martian inquisitors, with many messages from readers in need of work:

They could not have known that the Wall Street crash would take place months later, precipitating the Great Depression that would send unemployment rates in the UK soaring yet further.

Some readers, imagining Martians to be more advanced than humans, requested cures for cancer and other ailments, while others sought information about their religion. The Martians were invited by several participants to join the League of Nations, while one more cautious reader first wanted to know if they were “hostile and warlike”.

Much has changed in the past 97 years but the wit of Guardian readers has not. Among the responses were inquiries about whether the Martians would like to buy any coal – cash up front – and a sporting challenge to the Martian Test cricket team. One self-deprecating golfer asked:

About my drive at the eleventh, has it reached you yet?

The winning entry, from DW Hall of Buxton, played it straight:

A friendly word between the stars:
Peace on the Earth: goodwill to Mars

But the editors of the day also awarded a special prize of a book to the youngest entrant, a seven-year-old from Norfolk, who asked simply:

Do you eat?

Later challenges to readers included asking what they would do if they inherited an island in the Pacific, inviting ideas for a new Christmas-themed radio show, and asking what they thought someone who had been away for 20 years would make of the world today.

One week, readers were even tasked with coming up with a new competition for the Manchester Guardian, to which one reader submitted an “extremely complicated” mathematical puzzle involving diagrams made out of pink cardboard.

It is regrettable that Guardian readers’ remarkable minds are no longer being mined for ideas, but perhaps it’s time to change that. If you have an idea for a new competition or puzzle, we’d love to hear about it.

Clue of the week

What goes with swinging – is it sex parties? (7)

This week’s clue comes from Guy in the FT Weekend. “Parties” indicates an anagram of the words “is it sex”, which can be rearranged to make the word SIXTIES, often accompanied by the word “swinging” in descriptions of the decade that brought us the Beatles, Mary Quant and the contraceptive pill.

Readers’ cluing contest

Last week we asked you to supply a clue for the word SCARF. There were several strong entries playing with the nickname Scarface, while several others made use of the carpentry joint.

The runners up this week, though, are Gary Barwick’s “Stole vehicle in San Francisco”, and Phil Russell’s “Wrap your chops around a wrap?”.

The winner is David Feldman’s short but sweet double definition:

Neck warmer? (5)

“Neck” (as in to eat quickly) and “warmer” (as in something that keeps you toasty) combine to describe a scarf, which would also work in a US-style crossword.

This week, the word we’d like you to write a clue for is MARTIAN. Please send entries to [email protected].